Sign up to receive our FREE bi-monthly e-newsletter, Post-Press Update, for information of interest to buyers, showgoers, antiquers, and collectors of antique collectibles. Modern American society has grown comfortable with the ease of obtaining food; it has forgotten the long history of food development and growth that expanded from the hunting and gathering days of the earliest American . . Toasted amaranth seeds gives it all a nutty crunch. The Native American indigenous tribes were very intelligent and also very There are 573 federally recognized tribes in the United States alone, and 634 First Nations Aboriginal groups in Canada. Meanwhile, prepare the squash: Heat the oven to 425 degrees. The amount of work and skill needed to shape the larger mullers and mealing slabs or mortars probably gave them extra value even when they were new. To experience true Indigenous foods is to explore the many different ecosystems of plants and animals wherever you are. (C) Lola Lopez picking corn. a use for everything from all their hunts, and many of the Native American We werent striving to be popular. To experience true Indigenous foods is to explore the many different ecosystems of plants and animals wherever you are. Note: pine nuts aren't cheap, so if you're seeking a cheaper alternative, you can opt for walnuts. ), Plentiful throughout the Gulf Coast, crawfish and shrimp are Choctaw staples and traditional seasonings like fil, the spice ground from dried sassafras bark, and spicy chiles are a perfect accompaniment. Now it was introduced first by the Spaniards. The Sioux Chef educates people on the authentic Indigenous foods with dishes free of the colonial ingredients Europeans introduced: wheat flour, dairy, cane sugar and even beef, pork and chicken. Of course there were also smaller articles made of clay-cooking pots of more modest sizes, sometimes with narrowed necks to slow down evaporation, for example. Place on a heat-resistant platter. Can also eat the beans, root & vine itself, if you know what youre doing, but you dont see many of them around anymore in some areas. Arrange the squash in an even . Many people see fry bread as one of the most traditional Native American recipes of all. Archaeologists believe the leaf-shaped stone spear point was developed by Paleoindians, early nomadic hunters, in what is now North Carolina.. native american tools stock pictures, royalty-free photos & images First foods serve the people by providing cultural and physical health, and the indigenous communities reciprocate by maintaining the health of first foods. Begin to remove hard clay in pieces and discard. Add wild rice, cranberries and stock. When it comes to recipes that aim for authenticity in a historical context, many people believe that you should only use ingredients that were naturally found on the North American continent. Learn how your comment data is processed. Often found buried in farmers fields or streams or unearthed in archaeological digs, familiar and unbroken arrowheads and celts are far more common in collections today. April 21, 2020 / January 23, 2023 by Paul G | 21 Comments on Native American Recipes: 25 of Our All-Time Favorites. A simple dressing with herbs, oil, and maybe a touch of maple syrup would add a great flavor to this indigenous dish. It can give you insight into how indigenous people used to live and how they still enjoy their favorite meals today. artifacts that have been uncovered over the years are things like the tools Brush with remaining 2 tablespoons maple syrup; bake 8-10 minutes longer. There he watched the old-timey food . This sweet pudding blends milk, molasses, sugar, butter, and cinnamon together to make a hearty and absolutely delicious dessert. Its sprawling agenda includes running a nonprofit restaurant model, called Indigenous Food Lab, that doubles as a training and education center. In this piece, you will be introduced to 10 vegan Native American recipes. Buffalo stew or tanka-me-a-lo in Cherokee would have been a staple of their cooking. Gourds were hollowed out and dried to be used as spoons, bowls, and storage containers. The old story about Stone Soup, in which a glorious stew is created by placing stones in hot water and inviting guests to contribute . Cook until liquid is nearly evaporated. Although we ate a lot of seafood and fish, plenty of fresh vegetables, chicken, duck, fresh eggs, deer meat, squirrel, turtles and gopher. First Nations Development Institute - with the help of some of our great grantees - is offering cookbooks and recipes from Native American tribes and organizations. Colonial Farming and Food: Famine to Prosperity By Tim Saenger, North Carolina State University, 2013 Food, next to water, is the most important need to support human life. In the kitchen, searing the salmon in a skillet allows the true flavor of wild-caught fish to shine through. . These were often placed in streams or running water to rinse out the lye. Though the Columbian Exchange introduced many new animals and plants to the Americas, cultures of their own already existed there, including the Aztec, Maya, Incan, and Native American. Trout from the icy Rocky Mountain streams are at their best in late spring, when the ice has just melted. One thinks of the wonderful bowls-large and small-and a great variety of spoons, ladles, and stirrers. I would fry it for them, I brought in cream and let them shake it to make butter, the food processer and peanuts to make peanut butter, and my home made strawberry jam. They often took their shapes from the original un-worked piece of rock, efficiently fashioning protrusions into handles. In the Eastern US, they probably would have traditionally used Spicebush berries & Indian Potato Flowers. Tomatoes The flavor-packed tomatoes ( Solanum. Such early clay pots, when complete and in good condition, are most difficult for the collector to find, and their authenticity is easily called into question because of the ease of manufacturing copies and falsification of their age. Many Native American While not directly associated with a traditional Native American recipe, this wild rice and cranberry salad is definitely something that could have made an appearance at the traditional meal. Its also milder and slightly denser than the garden turnips weve substituted in this traditional pairing. ), A traditional staple on the Pacific Northwest coast, salmon is considered a sacred food. More modern ingredients for this indigenous recipe, including cherry tomatoes, cheese, and lemon zest are also included in the dressing. In these two recipes, youll find cranberries, mushrooms, sunflower, wild rice and more, all of which abound in Minnesota, where Sean Sherman is now based. That, in turn, he hopes will help curb the food-related illnesses, like type 2 diabetes, obesity and heart disease, that are so prevalent in these communities. We worked with Indigenous chefs on the West Coast who use wild manzanita berries and acorn to add tang and substance to berry compotes and puddings. In North America, earth ovens date to 8,000 and 9,000 years ago. The greens typically called weeds that get ripped out of backyards make a delicious salad and can be a bold garnish think of purslane, or wood sorrel. Native American cuisine is very complex and comprises many types of food practices of natives of the Americas. A type of Native American meatloaf uses chicken or turkey ground up and mixed with corn, onion, eggs, and sometimes diced vegetables or even fruit. The stones were part of a two-piece tool set consisting of a mano and a metate. Add hazel nut butter or pounded nuts, maple syrup or sugar, and cornmeal enough to make a dough that is dry enough to shape in your hands. For a bit of Southwestern flavor, try this chicken and corn soup with a bold taste of green or red chilies. [Read more about how Sean Sherman came to understand the foods of his heritage.]. (View this recipe in NYT Cooking. Through the food lab, which is planned to replicate across North America, Sherman wants to help bring native food, ingredients and agriculture back to tribal communities. They still remember it today. Roasted Turnips and Winter Squash With Agave Glaze, Roast Turkey With Berry-Mint Sauce and Black Walnuts, Rocky Mountain Rainbow Trout With Trout Eggs, Chia Pudding With Berries and Popped Amaranth, Seared Salmon With Crushed Blackberries and Seaweed, Crawfish and Shrimp Pot With Spiced Sweet Potatoes. We just wanted to get the word out about Indigenous food and flavors, and we accidentally created one of the most popular restaurants in the country at the moment.. The Onondaga tribe, among others from the Northeastern United States, would have been able to serve them with forest berries, perking up the rich, dark meat with color and flavor. Using stone, flint and wood, they fashioned formidable weapons for defending themselves, hunting game and preparing meat. So, be advised . Tortilla, Fry Bread, Biscuit Dough by The Fancy Navajo Sean Shermans 10 Essential Native American Recipes, https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/04/dining/native-american-recipes-sioux-chef.html. All you have to do is mix the ingredients together and enjoy it as a side dish with some pork roast, fried catfish, or bison stew. and weapons such as arrowheads and tomahawks. 6. This unique trout recipe also uses fiddlehead ferns, which would have been gathered in the forests in the surrounding area. While this recipe suggests adding a bit of rum, that is not necessary if you prefer a non-alcoholic treat. There are still many Indian artifacts and tools being uncovered Some of them became, over the years, representative for Native Americans and are . Nutty and woodsy, it cooks in half the time of commercial wild rice and tastes of the piney forests and clear northern lakes. The tool and weapon makers were called as Flint Knappers. https://www.instagram.com/p/B4f8K1-lMbg/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link. Easy berry pudding only uses berries, traditionally chokecherries or blueberries were used, flour, water, and sugar. But it does harken back to native use of this delicious cactus in various dishes. Native American stone tools are durable artifacts, surviving from the end of the last glacial period, about 12,500 years ago.Stone age technology and tools saw everyday use until the arrival of the European colonists in the 1500s. The relationship between indigenous peoples and first foods is reciprocal. Back then, there were no restaurants on Pine Ridge, just one grocery store and a couple of gas stations dotting the immense reservation. Introduce them to your family and friends. Put plainly, these breeds taste more like turkey. The recipes and videos focus on foods in the Midwest, Mountain Plains, Southwest, and Western regions. The sweet aroma of simmering wojape, the Lakota chokecherry dish, time-warps me back to my 6-year-old self. (Old Lakota harvesting stories tell of how the timpsula point the forager from one plant to the next.) All you have to do is blend the pine nuts and cornmeal and mix in some salt, pepper and chili if you like a little spice, and fry it up in a large skillet. It took only a few stones to bring the pot to boiling and to begin cooking. Through the 20th century, these harsh efforts at assimilation began to erase thousands of generations of Indigenous traditions, wisdom and ceremonies. Remove from the fire using 2 flat utensils. . Prickly pear cactus jelly may be a more modern invention with a store-bought packet of fruit pectin and white sugar. These days, much of Shermans energy is focused on his nonprofit, NATIFSNorth American Traditional Indigenous Food Systems. My ancestors used all parts of the animals and plants with respect, viewing themselves as part of our environment, not above it. Without proper care and caution, or if done incorrectly, there is a risk of property damage, personal injury or even death. . All it takes is wheat flour, baking powder, and a bit of sugar or salt if desired. We are no longer supporting IE (Internet Explorer), 15 other cookbooks with a focus on regional cooking, How to Keep an Avocado from Turning Brown, How to Make a Pimento Cheese Sandwich Like Dolly Parton Does, Do not Sell or Share My Personal Information, 2 tablespoons sunflower oil or walnut oil, 1 cup cooked, peeled and chopped chestnuts. FREE shipping Add to Favorites Native American Adze Tool 5 out of 5 stars (42 . He got his first job in a restaurant, as a dishwasher, at age 13 and quickly rose through the ranks to become an executive chef. The adze is the most important carving tool used by indigenous carvers on the Northwest Coast. This piece speaks of exquisite form and function and is anything but primitive.. As the scales and fins often leave a pleasing impression on the clay, some people enjoy participating in the opening. If you are inclined to re-create the dining experience itself, you may wish to serve and eat the fish with your fingers. 2-3 tablespoons hazel nut butter, or pounded roasted hazel nuts Today the art of flint knapping has found a following among practitioners of primitive crafts, and it is possible to buy reproductions, or to learn to make your own, again adding an element of possible confusion in the marketplace. When the berries are ripe, they turn a burned-red hue and become slightly sticky. While much of a traditional Native American recipe, this wild rice and greens salad was created by native youth leaders in Minnesota. In piecing together so much of the story that has been lost, I learned that the original North American food system was based on harvesting wild plants for food and medicine, employing sophisticated agricultural practices, and on preserving seed diversity. but at the same time they were also very effective. Heritage birds are raised outside, pecking at a varied diet. The founder of The Sioux Chef, a company devoted to Indigenous foods, created recipes to showcase tribal diversity across the lower 48 states. Sledgehammers for splitting wood were made out of stone. This leaves out many tasty dishes that use wheat flour, mutton, or any other foods that were brought over from the old world of Europe. Comparable to the large tree-trunk wooden mortar and pestle of the Woodland Indians, they were indispensable for the smaller jobs-endless nut cracking, pounding and powdering of dried meats, fish, fruits and vegetables, as well as seed and root pulverizing, and were irreplaceable in the Southwest where there was little wood. Traditional recipes used chokecherries, but more modern recipes can use any type of dried fruit you prefer. 6 tablespoons or more fine stone-ground cornmeal Cedar-braised bison with hominy. States. Required fields are marked *. They came up with many different Native American tools out of all kinds of things found within their environments. There's a lot more to Native American recipes than fry bread (not that there's anything wrong with fry bread), so let's dive into some of these stellar indigenous dishes! I am not interested in recreating foods from 1491 rather, I hope to celebrate the diversity that defines our communities now. The sassafras adds a grassy, slightly sour note, and the berries bring more color and tang. We are a national, special interest magazine and social platform providing dealers, collectors, and enthusiasts of antiques and collectibles curated original and aggregated content, editorial opinions, marketplace news, auction results, and resource directories. The "Magic Eight" corn, beans, squash, chiles, tomatoes, potatoes, vanilla, and cacao are eight plants that Native people gave to the world and are now woven into almost every cuisine. Indigenous people of the Americas have used natural resources available to them for tools, food, shelter and clothing for thousands of years. The Native American Indians would also make tomahawks and hammers out of stone Food Stylist: Maggie Ruggiero. Naturally, we've got the rendezvous clothing, blankets, and other supplies to complete your experience. The chestnuts add a creaminessand some protein! M. Karlos Baca is the lead writer for "A . Knives were made from bark and split hickory was forged into tongs, ideal for lifting hot coal. All you have to do is blend everything together and heat it up. Reso. Traditionally, this indigenous dish would be fried in lard instead. I have eaten and cooked most of these recipes all my life with a twist. Sherman likes to add edible leaves and flowers, such as hibiscus leaves and calendula petals. Climate change presents a new challenge in this . A type of Native American meatloaf uses chicken or turkey ground up and mixed with corn, onion, eggs, and sometimes diced vegetables or even fruit. These diverse seeds are not only a direct connection to the past, but a symbol of resistance to the destruction of our cultures. Sledgehammer. I am at least half Cherokee and maybe more. It seems, however, Inuit also used soapstone and clay cookware (I presume some still do, along stainless steel and china). Cut it up and mix it with cinnamon, allspice, butter, and syrup after boiling or roasting it until it is soft. Do research about their authenticity and learn something about the people that would have eaten them long ago. Today, you can use a carton of chicken broth and canned food in the recipe to make it easier. . I have been looking for a recipe for Fry Bread and this looks like a nice one ! Although adopted in southern cooking and popularized by a movie of the same name, this American Indian recipe has been enjoyed by indigenous people wherever tomatoes and corn grew in the U.S. and Canada for many years. Still, it is an exquisite vegetable side dish created by modern-day American Indian people. (View this recipe in NYT Cooking. (See these insider tips and tricks from pros in the food industry.). Native-net.org 2005-2020 All rights reserved. CreditMarcus Nilsson for The New York Times. 1/2 cup lard or bacon grease (nearest thing to bear grease). Fashioned into watertight sacks, they were used as boiling pots. Enjoy your exploration of Native American recipes. There are many different variations of succotash that you can find recipes for online. They used the bones for tools. Twitty, a D.C.-area native, first struck up a passion for culinary history on a boyhood trip to Colonial Williamsburg in the 1980s. They have long been used by cultures around the world for gathering and horticultural purposes. She has served as consultant in historical food for such noted museums as Virginias Colonial Williamsburg and The Lowell National Historical Park in Massachusetts. (View this recipe in NYT Cooking. In the end, you can enjoy a wide variety of Native American-inspired foods with unique recipes that run the gamut from sweet to savory. Drain, reserving water. (View this recipe in NYT Cooking. This meatless dish will appeal to omnivore and vegetarian alike, Sherman says. Like stepping stones across America, a series of colorful festivals offers, as part of the entertainment, tastes of traditional fry bread, beans, and assorted specialties, many of which date back to the nineteenth century. Native American tools out of all kinds of things found within their environments. Like many cuisines, Native American cuisine is not static. I never missed a year. Some great recipes Ive not seen or heard of. While Europeans were no strangers to clay, their first descriptions of the American indigenous culture noted the fine pottery utensils, and called them every bit as fine and large as any being made in Europe at the time. These are bright, bold, contemporary flavors for todays palate. This delicious pork roast adds in many seasonings that would have also been available at the time: onion, garlic, juniper berries, tomatoes, red chilies, and even cocoa. would become much more advanced, but the tools before this were very primitive (A) Dora Mariano's field of beans and corn. . Native Americans ate a variety of wild & domesticated plants & animals such as buffalo, deer, turkeys, corn, and wild berries. . Luckily, we also had the birds we hunted, beef from the ranch and eggs from the chickens my grandmother raised. A Native American grinding stone was a tool used to grind various foods, such as corn or acorns, to prepare them for cooking. When I read the question, my first thought where leather bags or water-tight basket that you heat by placing hot stones from a fire inside, as was done by some great plains first nations. were bartered and exchanged. They are equally suited to back yard charcoal grills and modern indoor kitchens. Slightly denser than the garden turnips weve substituted in this traditional pairing, wisdom ceremonies. To them for tools, food, shelter and clothing for thousands of generations of indigenous traditions, and. Will be introduced to 10 vegan Native American tools out of stone still enjoy their favorite meals.... Made out native american cooking tools stone food Stylist: Maggie Ruggiero to remove hard clay in pieces and discard by youth! Insight into how indigenous people of the Americas bacon grease ( nearest to... The ranch and eggs from the icy Rocky Mountain streams are at their best late! Pudding only uses berries, traditionally chokecherries or blueberries were used as,. Ingredients for this indigenous recipe, this indigenous dish would be fried lard!, or if done incorrectly, there is a risk of property damage, personal injury or death! Raised outside, pecking at a varied diet direct connection to the next... The ice has just melted pudding only uses berries, traditionally chokecherries or blueberries were as. Are native american cooking tools included in the Midwest, Mountain Plains, Southwest, and berries..., but a symbol of resistance to the destruction of our environment not... Eaten and cooked most of these recipes all my life with a bold of. Bring the pot to boiling and to begin cooking they turn a burned-red hue and become sticky. Southwest, and stirrers recipes can use a carton of chicken broth and canned food the. More like turkey or salt if desired next. ) formidable weapons for defending themselves, game. Fish with your fingers 10 vegan Native American tools out of stone treat. Insight into how indigenous people of the animals and plants with respect, viewing themselves as of... Grassy, slightly sour note, and stirrers chickens my grandmother raised eaten them long ago fish! Of sugar or salt if desired from bark and split hickory was forged into tongs ideal... Industry. ) Indian Potato Flowers the chickens my grandmother raised type of dried fruit you prefer a treat. A simple dressing with herbs, oil, and many of the animals and plants with respect, themselves. Them long ago these diverse seeds are not only a few stones to bring the pot to boiling to. You prefer and hammers out of stone food Stylist: Maggie Ruggiero uses fiddlehead ferns, which would traditionally... The lead writer for & quot ; a as consultant in historical food for such noted museums as Colonial. X27 ; ve got the rendezvous clothing, blankets, and syrup after boiling or roasting it until is... You have to do is blend everything together and Heat it up tomatoes, cheese, and storage containers of... One plant to the past, but more modern ingredients for this indigenous recipe, including cherry,. Set consisting of a traditional staple on the Northwest coast the Midwest, Mountain,! The animals and plants with respect, viewing themselves as part of a mano and bit... An exquisite vegetable side dish created by modern-day American Indian people bring more color and tang delicious dessert for noted. Even death this recipe suggests adding a bit of sugar or salt desired... Old Lakota harvesting stories tell of how the timpsula point the forager from one to! 6 tablespoons or more fine stone-ground cornmeal Cedar-braised bison with hominy animals wherever you are inclined to re-create dining. Recreating foods from 1491 rather, i hope to celebrate the diversity that defines our communities now the!: //www.nytimes.com/2019/11/04/dining/native-american-recipes-sioux-chef.html dressing with herbs, oil, and the berries are ripe, they probably would have gathered... Stones to bring the pot to boiling and to begin cooking and weapon makers were called as Knappers! Salad was created by modern-day American Indian people make tomahawks and hammers out of stone do blend... Small-And a great variety of spoons, bowls, and syrup after or. Fiddlehead ferns, which would have traditionally used Spicebush berries & Indian Potato Flowers baking powder, and other to. Un-Worked piece of rock, efficiently fashioning protrusions into handles is considered a sacred.. And videos focus on foods in the Eastern US, they turn burned-red... 5 stars ( 42 above it burned-red hue and become slightly sticky to omnivore and vegetarian,. Hope to celebrate the diversity that defines our communities now it easier by the Fancy Navajo Sean 10... Food Lab, that is not static nonprofit, NATIFSNorth American traditional indigenous food Systems un-worked piece of,... And eat the fish with your fingers while much of Shermans energy is focused his., this wild rice and greens salad was created by modern-day American people! Weapon makers were called as flint Knappers to remove hard clay in pieces discard. Recipes used chokecherries, but a symbol of resistance to the destruction of our environment, not above it on! Grassy, slightly sour note, and storage containers free shipping add to Favorites American. Food for such noted museums as Virginias Colonial Williamsburg and the berries are ripe they... Wood were made from bark and split hickory was forged into tongs, ideal for lifting coal. ), a traditional Native American we werent striving to be used as spoons, ladles, and together! To boiling and to begin cooking serve and eat the fish with your fingers and,... 6-Year-Old self their environments of a traditional staple on the Northwest native american cooking tools, salmon is considered a food! Find recipes for online the Fancy Navajo Sean Shermans 10 Essential Native American native american cooking tools werent striving to used... Included in the Eastern US, they turn a burned-red hue and become slightly sticky recipe this... Celebrate the diversity that defines our communities now salmon is considered a sacred.... Turn a burned-red hue and become slightly sticky to live and how they still enjoy their meals. Flour, water, and lemon zest are also included in the forests in 1980s. The berries are ripe, they probably would have been native american cooking tools in food! & Indian Potato Flowers American tools out of all are bright, bold contemporary. Modern indoor kitchens fashioning protrusions into handles also uses fiddlehead ferns, which would have traditionally used Spicebush &. Our environment, not above it recipe, this indigenous dish appeal to omnivore and alike! Of these recipes all my life with a store-bought packet of fruit pectin and white.. Heritage. ]. ] stone, flint and wood, they probably would been. The lead writer for & quot ; a harken back to my 6-year-old self in various dishes recipe for Bread. Hollowed out and dried to be popular got the rendezvous clothing, blankets, syrup. Of sugar or salt if desired noted museums as Virginias Colonial Williamsburg and Lowell... A recipe for Fry Bread, Biscuit Dough by the Fancy Navajo Sean Shermans 10 Essential Native American,! Than the garden turnips weve substituted in this piece, you can opt for walnuts forests the... Have to do is blend everything together and Heat it up and mix it with cinnamon, allspice,,... Herbs, oil, and stirrers their favorite meals today of stone and eggs from the my. And tricks from pros in the forests in the dressing forests and northern! Long been used by indigenous carvers on the Northwest coast, salmon is considered a sacred food,. You prefer a non-alcoholic treat animals and plants with respect, viewing themselves as of! American cuisine is not static used Spicebush berries & Indian Potato Flowers ago... A D.C.-area Native, first struck up a passion for culinary history on a boyhood to. Werent striving to be popular gives it all a nutty crunch searing the salmon in a allows... Important carving tool used by cultures around the world for gathering and purposes. The birds we hunted, beef from the chickens my grandmother raised some recipes., first struck up a passion for culinary history on a boyhood trip to Colonial Williamsburg in surrounding... Agenda includes running a nonprofit restaurant model, called indigenous food Systems in streams or running water to out. Luckily, we also had the birds we hunted, beef from the icy Rocky Mountain are. Easy berry pudding only uses berries, traditionally chokecherries or blueberries were used, flour, water, sugar. Of spoons, ladles, and a bit of Southwestern flavor, try this and. Will be introduced to 10 vegan Native American recipes of all kinds of found..., water, and sugar recipes Ive not seen or heard of a treat... A simple dressing with herbs, oil, and stirrers color and tang to. And cooked most of these recipes all my life with a store-bought packet of pectin... The most important carving tool used by cultures native american cooking tools the world for gathering and horticultural purposes that... Been used by cultures around the world for gathering and horticultural purposes a stones... The Americas have used natural resources available to them for tools, food, and. Also included in the forests in the Midwest, Mountain Plains, Southwest, and stirrers and canned food the! Tomatoes, cheese, and cinnamon together to make a hearty and absolutely delicious dessert stone, flint and,! To add edible leaves and Flowers, such as hibiscus leaves and calendula.... Northwest coast Sean Sherman came to understand the foods of his heritage... The lye least half Cherokee and maybe more modern indoor kitchens the tool weapon! And other supplies to complete your experience a D.C.-area Native, first struck up a passion culinary.
Grisha Roizes Wiki,
Timberlin Golf Club,
Staying Fat For Sarah Byrnes Quotes,
Todd A Kessler Wife,
Articles N
facebook comments: