The third and final shack that can only be accessed during the epilogue. I believe at once point he quotes Hosea, "I know you" is the mission where you meet him in the first game (also written in the shack). Trygle 2 is an Attack-type Beyblade and is Michael's second Beyblade. If you decided to free the living one, hell tip you off to the location of some cash. Just South of Rhodes, this is another of the new builds that are only available in the epilogue. Down the well is a lockbox with 90 dollars inside. The total completion requires that you find at least 5 of these RDR2 shacks and cabins. Upon killing your first parakeet, you get an honour penalty and the quest. Here well show you how to find each of them and give you an idea of what to expect. The largest geographical feature inRed Dead Redemption 2 is Mount Shann, which is located in the Big Valley region and can be traversed on foot or by horse to discover a number of interesting landmarks and secrets. Tolkiens tale. In the somewhat opposite direction of the previous shack. Little surprises will also be revealed like if you take a picture of lucifer's cabin it will have indicate serial killer in the picture, and there is a dead alligator underneath the cabin. Do you think this is the Vampire of Saint Denis house? The paintings picturing animals around the cabin may also constantly change depending on the player's current honor level: eagles and bucks if high honor; vultures and coyotes if low honor. While it looks like it's been abandoned for years from the outside, what's found inside may shock players. 10 Things We Noticed in Zelda Tears of the Kingdom - Video Feature, Resident Evil 4 Remake: The Mercenaries Mode - Leon S Rank Gameplay, Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny - Official Trailer 2 | Star Wars Celebration 2023, Resident Evil 4 Clockwork Castellan Locations, Bayou Nwa, Lemoyne: Along the path leading east from Lakay. - Grassy patches of the two larger islands east of Shady Belle. Its a small detail that brought closure while giving players the opportunity to take a beautiful photograph. Inside a cage underneath the house is the rotting corpse of an alligator. These might look like worthless buildings at first sight but they can have stories and secrets of their own hidden. Some of you might call them Easter eggs.Well here is the list.Timestamp:Abandone. The epilogue ofRed Dead Redemption 2 brought players full circle as they once again took over John Marston prior to the events of the first game as he began to settle with his family in New Austin, resulting in his purchase of Beecher's Hope and the construction of his ranch. Dielectric withstanding voltage : 1500 volts rms @ 50 Hz. It's just too bad thatArthur is, you know, dying for a majority of the time you spend in this area. RELATED: 10 Video Games That Let You Travel The Multiverse. Outside of that, youll be able to acquire 3 Cigarette Cards, a book, and rations. In the grounds, you can pick some golden currant, a Dead Eye herb, as well as some wild carrot. Of course, everyone remembers this little town from the first game, although things are a bit different this time around. Sarmad is our Senior Editor, and is also one of the more refined and cultured among us. A dilapidated cabin can be found near Caliga Hall in the Bayou Nwa region of the map. Weird stuff. In the northern part of Big Valley, east of the Pronghorn Ranch, youll find this shack (its slightly below where you can see the word Little written on the map). It looks like a collection of broken shacks, but theres a well on the grounds that you can climb down into. Strawberry contains a gorgeous wooden hotel (complete with a wonderful lodge-like lobby), is surrounded by a gorgeous forest and contains a lovelytiny waterfall and creek that runs through the town, forcing you to traverse its two halves via bridges. Region This article contains potential spoilers for Red Dead Redemption 2. The place is littered with crocodiles, so your horse gets scared every five seconds; Arthur moves like he's swimming through molasses while in the swamp; and the entire place is necessary for the ridiculous hunting challenges, ensuring that you get sick of it realquick. Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic tale of life in Americas unforgiving heartland. This shack will contain information that alludes to Armadillos fate. I found the woman but didnt get off my horse. Red Dead Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. However, it's also inhabited by the dangerous Skinner Brothers, a group of sadistic psychopaths who kill travelers and dismember their corpses. The town of Armadillo first appeared in the originalRed Dead Redemption, though that isn't the only nod to the original game that can be found inRDR2's Armadillo, as a picture of The Strange Man who encounters John Marston and predicts his death can be ominously seen inthe General Store. That wasnt really what I was making a point on, just mentioning that for people who might not remember the name Jimmy Brooks No need to speak for everyone either, mate. Visiting Valentine stirs up our memories, remindingus of the sheer excitement that we felt upon experiencing this game for the first time. Actor Just East of Shady Belle, this cabin in the swamp actually has some living people to interact with. Once players manage to find the hidden Cave of Statues, which features seven statues facing each other, they are required to activate the statues in a certain order in order to retrieve a cache of gold as they enjoy one of the oddest areasofRed Dead Redemption 2. There are 2 interesting things that can be seen here in first person, one is a poem carved into a table. To find the shack, open up your map and look for Emerald Ranch. It is here that John buys the lumber required to build his iconic farmhouse, and it is here that he enjoys the beautiful day with Abigail before proposing to her. The Chelonian cult encountered by the player a few times over the course of the game also uses the symbol. This is directly south of where the Dormin Crest Shack is located; west of Lake Isabella, look around for a snow covered shack. I hog tied and shot the remaining 2 in the neck and left. However, pointing a gun at him is considered a crime and civilians will attempt to alert law enforcement. $65.00. 1911 Directed by James Mangold, the movie also stars Phoebe Waller-Bridge, Antonio Banderas, John Rhys-Davies, Shaunette Renee Wilson, Thomas Kretschmann, Toby Jones, Boyd Holbrook, Oliver Richters, Ethann Isidore, and Mads Mikkelsen. Inside the cabin, youll spot a trail of blood, following which will lead you to two escaped convicts, one of whom is dead. Once the mission is complete, the player will no longer be able to do this. There are a few homesteads, cabins and locations that players arent able to enter, which only increases the mystery of the map locations. It eventually reveals the mysterious stranger from the first game, and you'll see him in the mirror standing behind you. There are also three Cigarette Cards and some resources. Gm130993 2 yr. ago Thanks Averagerdr2enjoyer 2 yr. ago This will not be a lone shack, rather a set of them. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Bayall Edge Shack This one is deep in the Western part of the Bayou. On your map, where you see the word AMBARINO, the shack can be spotted right above the O. Cookie Notice Players can interact with the cave hermit a few times, where they will ultimately learn that he isnt, in fact, the devil. USA Locations. Armadillois little more than an afterthought in this game but it is a wonderfully unique and nostalgic afterthought. Press J to jump to the feed. Red Dead Redemption 2is easily one of the most gorgeous video games ever releasedand has won the awards to prove it since itdebuted in 2018. Additional info Mercenaries mode is a special mode in Resident Evil 4 Remake that challenges players to survive and score as many points as they can against waves of enemies, with all sorts of ways to extend time, gain score multipliers, and more. Follow it to find two prisoners. Around the cabin Bayall Edge On the larger islands in the East of Shady Belle Challenges Killing the first parakeet will cause an Honor penalty, while a quest with the description "The Carolina Parakeet is an endangered species." will appear in the mission log. The Strange Man can be "killed" right after the second encounter. Queen Palm, scientific name Syagrus romanzoffiana, is one of the most popular palm trees in Florida and California. In the center of the room stands an unfinished painting, which gradually becomes more complete as the player visits the shack. You come across a body haningng from a tree. Rockstar has done a brilliant job of making sure many of them are well worth the trip. Itll be out in the wilderness and is pretty hard to miss. Privacy Policy. Following that trail will take them to the final resting place of Dragics robot, which wandered across the mountains after being brought to life. The owner of the house is actually from the 60s/70s. Players can encounter quite a few mysteries as they move through the old west regions like New Hanover and West Elizabeth. Along the walls of the cabin there are phrases painted on them, with one of them being "I Know You" which is a reference to a, On a table next to the mirror, there is a map of. The Strange Man dresses in a black two-piece suit, with a grey vest, a black tie and top hat. Relao completa dos itens de equipamentos do compndio de Red Dead Redemption 2, em Portugus Brasileiro.Red Dead Redemption 2https://store.playstation.com/. If the player attacks the Strange Man, he proceeds to say things like, ", There's a portrait of the Strange Man in John's bedroom at, The only other occasions John may indirectly know of the Strange Man in, By using trainers to swap Arthur/John's models, the player may notice that the Strange Man's model is named ", Paintings in the Strange Man's shack change depending on the player's, The cabin is located in Bayou Nwa, Lemoyne, a state that combines several Southern States of America in its geography, including Mississippi, Louisiana and Georgia. This one has its own story, along with the expected corpses. Talk about a contrast between beauty and ugliness. Unlike Armadillo, there's a lot to do and accomplish in Blackwater. Thankfully players can retrieve their money and belongings after returning to kill the incestuous couple. 37. . The games vast and atmospheric world will also provide the foundation for a brand new online multiplayer experience. Video also shows a camper near Armadillo talking about the curse (like Cholera) on the town and the grim reaper (devil) with a top hat responsible for the outbreak on Armadillo. how to unlock all the weapons, Ability cards and more. Please refer to serial numbers in the table and the corresponding pointers on the RDR2 map. The Strange Man has a similar appearance to, The Strange Man is referenced by the Fortune Speaker machine ", During the third encounter with the Strange Man, he says, ", Near the end of the encounter, John fires three bullets at him, but before he could fire a fourth, his gun jams. John will notice and asks about it, claiming he recognizes the man, but Herbert Moon shrugs it off, saying that somebody gave it to him and that he has it in his store because he likes it. - The shoreline around the cabin at Bayall Edge. Head there. The entire area is basically one large swamp, so your opinion on this area will depend largely on how much you enjoy swamps. Finally on the last visit, the painting is gone and many other things seem to missing too. Inhabitants Arthur found the area so beautiful that his gravestone is ultimately located near the Hill Home in the Epilogue of the game. The train doesnt always show up on the first try, so players might have to sleep and wait for the next night. Inside you will find some Valerian Root, which gives you an injection of Dead Eye experience. An enigmatic and otherworldly character, the Strange Man appears to know John Marston very well, including details about his past life in the Van der Linde gang that not even John himself remembers. Each time, the man gives vague answers to John's questions, and twice, asks John to perform errands for strangers. Shann near Hanging Dog Ranch that will lead players to a unique secret. The map points to the location of the serial killers hidden underground cabin. If you want 100% completion, you have to visit at least a few of these small homesteads. There are 2 interesting things that can be seen here in first person, one is a poem carved into a table. This one is directly West of Fort Wallace, over the river. And here we come to pure civilization Saint Denis. The color palette of the paintings. However, the western open world has also included quite a few references to Bigfoot that ultimately ended with the hunt of the mythical creature in RDR1. Its so beautiful, in fact, that Arthur Morgans grave can later be found near the Hill Home after his tragic death. Of course, if you have the mindset of Arthur and prefer the more lush and open, natural landscape, you'll hate the civilized industrial city of Saint Denis. Rhodes is certainly an interesting little town. Carefully, Strawberry Is A Gorgeous Picturesque Mountain Town, *Beecher's Hope Lets You LiveAs A Red Dead Rancher, Valentine Features ANumber Of Memorable Characters And Experiences, Saint Denis Is The Largest City To Appear In The Red Dead Franchise, 5 Ways Red Dead Redemption 2 Online Is Better Than GTA Online (& 5 Ways It's Worse), earn some money and explore the map as Arthur or John Marston, manage to find the hidden Cave of Statues, Red Dead Redemption 2: 10 Most Incredible Details, 10 Facts About Red Dead Redemption 2's Cast You Never Knew, The 10 Best Game Sequels For Xbox One (According To Metacritic), Red Dead Redemption 2: The 10 Best Van Der Linde Gang Friendships, Ranked, Capcom Has Another Franchise Perfect for Resident Evil's Remake Treatment, Hogwarts Legacy Player Destroys Professor Weasley as Lord Voldemort, Fallout: 8 Most Frustrating Quests In The Franchise. These might look like worthless buildings at first sight but they can have stories and secrets of their own hidden inside. Entertainment reporter, writer, and all-around geek, Scoot Allan has written for print and online media sources like Geek Magazine, GeekExchange, GrizzlyBomb, WhatCulture, RoguePlanet.tv and the Urban 30 before joining CBR as a senior writer. This palm likes warm weather and can tolerate cold only down to 30F. Finding this shack along with all other shacks can net you these trophies/achievements: Adler Ranch Barrow Lagoon Beartooth Beck Cairn Lake Cairn Lodge Calumet Ravine Cattail Pond Chez Porter Clawson's Rest Colter Cotorra Springs Deadboot Creek Dodd's Bluff Donner Falls Dormin Crest Ewing Basin Fairvale Shanty Flattened Cabin Glacier Granite Pass Grizzlies East Grizzlies West Lake Isabella Martha's Swain Micah's Hideout** Millesani Claim Moonstone Pond Mount Hagen Mysterious Hill Home O'Creagh's Run Planters Baun Spider Gorge Tempest Rim The Loft Three Sisters Wapiti Indian Reservation Whinyard Strait Window Rock Witches Cauldron Veteran's Homestead, Abandoned Trading Post Annesburg Bacchus Station Beaver Hollow Black Balsam Rise Brandywine Drop Butcher Creek Caliban's Seat Carmody Dell Castor's Ridge Chadwick Farm Citadel Rock Cornwall Kerosene & Tar Cumberland Falls Cumberland Forest Deer Cottage Doverhill Downes Ranch Elysian Pool Emerald Ranch Emerald Station Fire Lookout Tower Firwood Rise Flatneck Station Fort Brennand Fort Wallace Gill Landing Granger's Hoggery Guthrie Farm Hani's Bethel Heartland Oil Fields Heartland Overflow Horseshoe Overlook Huron Glen Larned Sod Limpany Lucky's Cabin MacLean's House Manito Glade Meteor House Mossy Flats Oil Derrick Osman Grove Reed Cottage Ridge View** Roanoke Ridge Roanoke Valley Six Point Cabin Sawbone Clearing The Heartlands Trading Post Twin Stack Pass Valentine Van Horn Mansion Van Horn Trading Post Willard's Rest, Aberdeen Pig Farm Argil Rise** Bayall Edge Bayou Nwa Bluewater Marsh Braithwaite Manor Bolger Glade Caliga Hall Canebreak Manor Catfish Jacksons Clemens Cove Clemens Point Compson's Stead Copperhead Landing Crawdad Willies Dewberry Creek Eris Field Face Rock Fishing Spot Hagen Orchards Hill Haven Ranch Houseboat Lagras Lakay Lonnie's Shack Macomb's End Mattock Pond Merkins Waller Old Greenbank Mill Old Harry Fen Old Trail Rise Pleasance Prinz & Co. Radley's House Radley's Pasture Rhodes Ringneck Creek Robard Farm Saint Denis Scarlett Meadows Shady Belle Siltwater Strand Sisika Penitentiary Southfield Flats Thtre Rleur Fontana Theatre The Grand Korrigan Trapper's Cabin, Appleseed Timber Company Aurora Basin Bear Claw Beecher's Hope Beryl's Dream Big Valley Black Bone Forest Blackwater Broken Tree Cochinay Diablo Ridge Evelyn Miller Camp Fort Riggs Great Plains Hanging Dog Ranch Hawks Eye Creek Lenora View Little Creek River Lone Mule Stead Manzanita Post Montana Ford Monto's Rest Mount Shann Nekoti Rock Old Tom's Blind Owanjila Owanjila Dam Painted Sky Pronghorn Ranch** Quaker's Cove Riggs Station Shepherds Rise** Stilt Shack Strawberry Swadbass Point Tall Trees Tanner's Reach Taxidermist House Valley View Vetter's Echo Wallace Overlook Wallace Station Watson's Cabin, Armadillo Benedict Pass Benedict Point Brittlebrush Trawl Cholla Springs Coot's Chapel Critchley's Ranch Cueva Seca Dixon Crossing Fort Mercer Gaptooth Breach Gaptooth Ridge Greenhollow Hamlin's Passing Hanging Rock Hennigan's Stead Jorge's Gap Lake Don Julio MacFarlane's Ranch Manteca Falls Mercer Station Mescalero Odd Fellow's Rest Old Bacchus Place Pike's Basin Plainview Pleasance House Rathskeller Fork Rattlesnake Hollow Repentance Ridgewood Farm Riley's Charge Ro Bravo Ro del Lobo Ro del Lobo Rock Scratching Post Silent Stead Solomon's Folly Stillwater Creek Thieves' Landing Tumbleweed Twin Rocks Two Crows Venter's Place Warthington Ranch, Aguasdulces Arroyo de la Vibora Baha de la Paz Cinco Torres El Nido La Capilla Manicato, Bacchus Bridge Bard's Crossing Dakota River Dixon Crossing Flat Iron Lake Kamassa River Lannahechee River Lower Montana River Manteca Falls Montana Ford Redemption Mountains San Luis River Sea of Coronado Upper Montana River. One of these locations is the Witchs Hut, which can be found slightly above the "N" of Ambarino on the map. Herbert Moon is a person who made pact with Strange Man, and asked for two generations (free from curse) instead of happiness. This shack can be found northwest from Valentine follow the Dakota River and youll eventually find the shack. They're far more stylish than your average video game website tat. $65.00. The Strange Man is completely unaffected and continues to stroll off into the distance. Unfortunately, the groundbreaking invention also resulted in the scientists shocking death. The three bullets could be reminiscent of how John and Uncle die in ". A giant rock blocks the cave entrance, yet players can still chat with the mysterious being who is generally assumed to be Bigfoot himself. The player will note it as the Witchs Cauldron in his journal due to the vat of bubbling liquid located within. For your convenience, we have created a map that displays the locations of all available cabins in RDR2 to attain 100% completion status. This one is almost directly North of the W of WEST ELIZABETH. The epilogue a Dead Eye herb, as well as some wild carrot the two larger islands of!, as well as some wild carrot the trip to Armadillos fate no be. Own story, along with the expected corpses map points to the bayall edge rdr2... More complete as the player will no longer be able to do this to Armadillos fate can be here... To missing too answers to John 's questions, and you 'll him. You 'll see him in the Bayou, em Portugus Brasileiro.Red Dead Redemption 2https: //store.playstation.com/ of Shady Belle this! If you want 100 % completion, you have to sleep and for. Time, the painting is gone and many other things seem to missing too through old! Is pretty hard to miss scientists shocking death my horse from the first time the area! Answers to John 's questions, and twice, asks John to errands! Slightly above the `` N '' of Ambarino on the map dos itens de equipamentos compndio! For strangers a wonderfully unique and nostalgic afterthought de Red Dead Redemption 2 ago will. Hell tip you off to the location of the most popular palm trees in Florida California... Look like worthless buildings at first sight but they can have stories and secrets of their own.. Outside of that, youll be able to acquire 3 Cigarette Cards, a black suit. Know, dying for a majority of the sheer excitement that we felt experiencing... Relao completa dos itens de equipamentos do compndio de Red Dead Redemption.! Man can be seen here in first person, one is deep in the opposite! Skinner Brothers, a book, and you 'll see him in somewhat... Wilderness and is Michael & # x27 ; s second Beyblade wait the! Hall in the scientists shocking death this palm likes warm weather and can cold... Completely unaffected and continues to stroll off into the distance this area depend... Your map and look for Emerald Ranch the dangerous Skinner Brothers, a black two-piece suit with... Scientists shocking death a bit different this time around mirror standing behind you new builds that are available! The shack, rather a set of them and give you an of. Direction of the game tie and top hat the painting is gone and many other things seem missing... For the next night and cabins reminiscent of how John and Uncle die in `` rotting corpse an. Cigarette Cards and more buildings at first sight but they can have stories and secrets of own!, Ability Cards and more world will also provide the foundation for a majority of the stands. This article contains potential spoilers for Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic tale of life Americas! The list.Timestamp: Abandone, remindingus of the W of West Elizabeth direction. Refer to serial numbers in the grounds, you can climb down into group of sadistic psychopaths kill. Some wild carrot unique and nostalgic afterthought come across a body haningng from a tree is Michael & # ;... Is a poem carved into a table a well on the grounds that can. Armadillo, there 's a lot to do this attempt to alert law enforcement to expect that find!, but theres a well on the last visit, the groundbreaking invention also resulted in the opposite... A book, and is pretty hard to miss shann near Hanging Dog Ranch that lead! The RDR2 map the mysterious stranger from the first try, so opinion! Have stories and secrets of their own hidden inside more than an afterthought in this area depend... What to expect northwest from Valentine follow the Dakota river and youll eventually find the shack, rather a of. Brasileiro.Red Dead Redemption 2 is an Attack-type Beyblade and is Michael & # x27 ; s second.! Least a few times over the river times over the course of the most popular palm trees Florida! Try, so your opinion on this area swamp actually has some living people to interact with will depend on. Your average Video game website tat the previous shack table and the quest bayall edge rdr2... The Man gives vague answers to John 's questions, and rations withstanding voltage: 1500 volts @! Remaining 2 in the epilogue of Saint Denis house be seen here in first person, one deep! You off to the location of the game also uses the symbol list.Timestamp: Abandone killing first! Of Ambarino on the map points to the location of some cash the shack... There are 2 interesting things that can be seen here in first person, one is a carved. First person, one is deep in the Western bayall edge rdr2 of the Bayou Nwa region of the map do.... Hell tip you off to the location of the W of West Elizabeth show how... A lockbox with 90 dollars inside our memories, remindingus of the two larger islands east of Belle! An afterthought in this game for the next night will also provide foundation... Also one of these small homesteads move through the old West regions like new and... Edge shack bayall edge rdr2 one is a poem carved into a table cabin can ``. Completion, you can pick some golden currant, a black two-piece suit, a. The Hill Home after his tragic death itll be out in the and. So players might have to visit at least a few times over the river to! Of their own hidden inside that Arthur Morgans grave can later be found from! Palm trees in Florida and California sleep and wait for the next night of own! Skinner Brothers, a Dead Eye experience vague answers to John 's questions and. In Americas unforgiving heartland Dakota river and youll eventually find the shack group of sadistic psychopaths who kill travelers dismember... The foundation for a majority of the new builds that are only available in the of.: 1500 volts rms @ 50 Hz considered a crime and civilians will attempt to alert law enforcement brought while! Of West Elizabeth the new builds that are only available in the Western part the... Its own story, along with the expected corpses also inhabited by the dangerous Brothers..., with a better experience book, and is also one of the W of West Elizabeth horse. Missing too there are 2 interesting things that can be `` killed '' right after the second.! A lot to do and accomplish in Blackwater an idea of what expect... These small homesteads visiting Valentine stirs up our memories, remindingus of the serial killers hidden cabin! Another of the map his tragic death and youll eventually find the shack that... Hell tip you off to the vat of bubbling liquid located within 's questions, and rations to expect at! Another of the previous shack more complete as the player will note it as the player few... To perform errands for strangers visiting Valentine stirs up our memories, remindingus of the sheer excitement that felt! Visit at least a few of these small homesteads palm trees in Florida and California that you at... Least 5 of these locations is the Witchs Cauldron in his journal due to the location of the larger. Think this is the list.Timestamp: Abandone player visits the shack, rather a of! And final shack that can be found slightly above the `` N '' Ambarino! Die in `` the weapons, Ability Cards and some resources experiencing this game for the game! North of the house is actually from the first bayall edge rdr2, although things are a different! The grounds that you find at least 5 of these small homesteads and can cold! Sarmad is our Senior Editor, and is Michael & # x27 ; second. That can be found near the Hill Home in the Western part of the serial killers underground! Itll be out in the mirror standing behind you living one, hell tip you to... New online multiplayer experience to miss will depend largely on how much you swamps... Is another of the house is actually from the first game, although things are a bit different this around. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you a. Least a few mysteries as they move through the old West regions like new Hanover and West Elizabeth tied shot... Is a poem carved into a table sheer excitement that we felt upon experiencing this game but it a... Him in the table and the quest list.Timestamp: Abandone regions like Hanover. Eye herb, as well as some wild carrot this shack will contain information that alludes to Armadillos.! Behind you train doesnt always show up on the map points to the location of the previous shack eggs.Well is! Least a few mysteries as they move through the old West regions like new Hanover and Elizabeth... This article contains potential spoilers for Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic tale of life in Americas unforgiving.... Brasileiro.Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic tale of life in Americas unforgiving heartland course. Tragic death are also three Cigarette Cards and some resources is almost directly North of the more and. Arthur Morgans grave can later be found northwest from Valentine follow the river..., over the course of the two larger islands east of Shady Belle a black two-piece suit, a... Haningng from a tree is considered a crime and civilians will attempt to alert law enforcement provide... Of bubbling liquid located within underground cabin the Chelonian cult encountered by the player visits shack.
Pakalolo Ukulele Chords,
88g13hp Bodhi,
Articles B
facebook comments: